About the Work of Art:
Dorothea Lange (1895–1965)
Woman of the High Plains “If You Die, You’re Dead–That’s
All.” Texas Panhandle, 1938
Gelatin silver print, 1960s
© The Dorothea Lange Collection, Oakland Museum of California,
City of Oakland, Gift of Paul S. Taylor Amon Carter Museum, Fort Worth, Texas
P1965.172.8
|
This expressive photograph captures the weary determination
of Great Plains women who stubbornly battled through one of the worst
natural disasters this country has ever endured—the dust bowl
of the 1930s. Lange originally created the image as part of her extensive
documentation of rural, depression-era America for the federal government’s
Farm Security Administration (FSA). She liked the photograph so much
that she added it to an evocative series of fifteen portraits of farm
women, paired with shots of their respective environments, in a book
called The American Country Woman (1967), designed to praise
“women of the American soil,” whom Lange called “the
roots of our country.”
The woman portrayed is Nettie Featherston, a migrant laborer’s
wife and mother of three. Lange took the picture in the Texas Panhandle
to document for the FSA farmland and families devastated by drought
and dust storms. The photograph’s title comes from a much larger
caption recording a conversation between Lange and Featherston, when
the latter woman said,
We made good money pullin’ bolls [cotton], when we could pull.
But we’ve had no work since March. When we miss, we set and eat
just the same. The worst thing we did was when we sold the car, but
we had to sell it to eat, and now we can’t get away from here.
We’d like to starve if it hadn’t been for what my sister
in Enid sent me. When it snowed last April we had to burn beans to keep
warm. You can’t get no relief here until you’ve lived here
a year. This county’s a hard county. They won’t help bury
you here. If you die, you’re dead, that’s all. 
Reading Nettie Featherston’s words and looking at her photograph,
we find a woman tested to the limits of endurance. Her family has been
on the verge of starvation, and work is scarce. She is wearing a dress
made out of a rough sack, her face is careworn, her hair is uncombed,
and her hand is on her forehead—a gesture of frustration and grief.
Her mouth is set in a tight line, perhaps to keep herself from crying.
Viewers cannot see Nettie’s eyes, and eyes are usually key elements
in a portrait. But do viewers need to see her eyes? What more would
her eyes tell viewers about her desperation than can already be learned
from her body language? Nettie is the antithesis of the “perfect
woman” epitomized by fashion models and movie stars who were avidly
portrayed in the popular press of the 1930s.
The elements of the photograph are quite simple: a central figure,
a strip of land, and a vast sky. The land and the sky are slightly blurred,
but the central figure of the woman is razor sharp. Nothing in the background
detracts the viewer from Nettie’s intense expression and tortured
stance. By photographing Nettie from a low camera angle, Lange has ennobled
her, creating a monumental figure that dwarfs both land and sky. Her
story is an age-old one of a human being's surviving in spite of the
odds. Nettie went on to live a long life, and at eighty–one she
told an interviewer:
I never much thought about living this long. I just didn’t
think we’d survive. If you want to know something, we’re
not living much better now than we did then—as high as everything
is. 
|